What Was Jesus Really Asking the Rich Young Ruler?
"Good Teacher, what good thing shall I do that I may have eternal life?" That's an excellent question! Be honest. You've probably asked or thought about that question yourself. In your desire to be good and pleased to God, you've wondered, am I doing the right things to ensure my eternal future?
Mature Christians understand that you cannot "do" anything to earn eternal life. Salvation is by grace alone; it's a gift. There's nothing you can do to earn it. But, being saved by grace is not a license to live any way we want. It requires that we live and follow God's commandments to live according to His ways.
The best biblical definition of someone who accepts this way of life is a disciple. A disciple is a follower; in this case, it’s being a follower of Christ. A disciple declares that life's path is not of his choosing but that of his master, Jesus. What He says is ultimately the truth he embraces and the direction the disciple will take. At no point on the journey does the disciple go off and do things of his choosing. Instead, his allegiance, his commitment, and devotion are to the master.
The question quoted earlier was asked of Jesus by the rich young ruler, a conversation Jesus had, which is found in three of the four gospels in the New Testament. When evaluated carefully, this story is one of the most challenging conversations Jesus has in the Gospels.
A wealthy young man approaches Jesus with what seems like a sincere question:
“Teacher, what good deed must I do to have eternal life?”
— Matthew 19:16 (ESV)
He appears morally serious. He knows the commandments. He has tried to live a good life. Jesus tells him to obey the seventh, sixth, eighth, ninth, and fifth commandments. He responds by telling Jesus that he has kept all of these since childhood, which is doubtful. Yet underneath his question is a problem many of us recognize: the belief that eternal life can be secured through our own effort.
Jesus’ response is often misunderstood. He then tells him that there's one other thing he must do. He has to sell everything, give to the poor, and follow him. This, of course, addressed the tenth commandment, covetousness, and greed, which reveals the real issue this ruler was dealing with. He thought he was doing all the right things on the outside, following all the commandments, yet his heart was wrapped up in his wealth, which he valued more than God. Wealth and riches can hinder a person from entering into everlasting life, but that's not the main point of this story.
Did He tell every Christian to sell everything they own? Is wealth itself wrong? Or was He asking this particular man to confront something deeper?
The rich young ruler’s story is not simply about money. It is about salvation, surrender, and what happens when something we possess begins to possess us.
A Man Looking for Assurance
The rich young ruler comes to Jesus wanting clarity. He wants to know what he must do to inherit eternal life. Jesus first directs him toward God’s commandments. The man responds that he has kept them since his youth.
On the surface, he appears to be everything people might admire: moral, disciplined, financially successful, and spiritually interested. But his question—“What do I still lack?”—reveals that he knows something is missing. Having done everything he thought he could do to gain eternal life, he still felt like he was falling short of obtaining it. The commandments that Jesus emphasized were all about how to treat other people, to which he responds, "All these things I have kept from my youth. What do I still lack?"
He has attempted to build confidence in his own obedience, but he has not found peace. Jesus does not give him another religious task to complete. Instead, He lovingly exposes the one area of life the man has not surrendered.
Jesus Looked at Him and Loved Him
Mark’s Gospel includes a detail that changes how we read the entire conversation:
“And Jesus, looking at him, loved him.”
— Mark 10:21 (ESV)
Jesus was not trying to humiliate this man. He was not condemning him for having wealth. He loved him enough to tell him the truth. Jesus saw that the ruler’s possessions had become more than possessions. Wealth had become his security, his identity, and the thing he could not imagine living without.
So Jesus invited him to sell what he had, give to the poor, and follow Him.
The command was personal because the idol was personal.
For this man, the barrier to following Jesus was not a lack of information or discipline. It was his unwillingness to release control of the one thing he valued most.
Was Jesus Commanding Every Christian to Sell Everything?
No. This passage should not be used as a universal command that every Christian must sell every possession.
Throughout the New Testament, we see believers with resources using them to serve God and others. Some opened their homes for the church. Others supported ministry, cared for the poor, and used their influence and wealth for kingdom purposes.
The issue is not whether a person has possessions. The issue is whether possessions have a person.
Jesus’ command to the rich young ruler exposed the specific thing that stood between him and wholehearted discipleship. For another person, that obstacle may be a relationship, a career, approval, comfort, reputation, achievement, or control.
Anything we refuse to place under Christ’s authority can become an idol.
The Real Issue Was Self-Reliance
The rich young ruler wanted to know what he could do to secure eternal life.
But salvation cannot be earned through moral effort, generosity, religious activity, or command-keeping. Eternal life is a gift of God’s grace, received through faith in Christ.
It is here when Jesus points to the real issue, the young man's self-reliance and his lack of devotion to God. The one thing in his life keeping him from his steadfast love for God was his possessions, so Jesus told him to give them up and, this time, make a genuine commitment to follow him. He invites him to be a disciple. To forsake his way and embrace God's way.
He wanted eternal life, but he did not want Jesus at the cost of his greatest source of security.
That is why the story is so searching. It asks each of us: Is there anything I want more than I want to follow Christ?
Wealth Is a Gift—but It Can Become a Rival
Wealth itself is not evil. Money can be used to provide for a family, support the church, meet needs, create opportunities, and advance the gospel.
But wealth is spiritually dangerous when it convinces us that we are self-sufficient.
Jesus later told His disciples:
“How difficult it will be for those who have wealth to enter the kingdom of God!”
— Mark 10:23 (ESV)
Many things in this world hinder people from fully committing to God; wealth is just one of them. For some, it's a relationship or a career. Whatever person, place, or thing one allows to have priority and influence in their life above God will keep them from being a faithful disciple of Christ.
The Bible is clear that if you love the world, the love of The Father (God) cannot reside in you. Money is a test of our commitment and love for God, but so is every other thing God has given to us. Being a disciple requires that we manage (steward) everything God has entrusted to us His way.
“ It’s not what you say that matters most; it’s what you do because it reveals what you believe. ”
We can accept the gift and reject the Giver by merely valuing the gift above the Giver. It's not what you say that matters most; it's what you do because it reveals what you believe. If you see money, a relationship, a career, or anything else as a means to obtain the value and the meaning you desire in life, it shows that this world and what people think about you is what's most important to you.
The difficulty is not that God’s grace is unavailable to wealthy people. The difficulty is that wealth can make it easier to trust what we can see and control instead of trusting God.
Money can promise comfort, security, status, and freedom. But it cannot save us. It cannot give us a new heart. It cannot provide the eternal life the rich young ruler was seeking.
What Does This Mean for Us?
The rich young ruler did not walk away because he lacked information. He walked away because he was grappling with the true cost of discipleship, possibly unwilling to surrender what mattered most to him.
The question this story raises is not merely, “Would I sell everything?”
The deeper questions are:
What do I look to for security besides God?
What would be hardest for me to surrender if Jesus asked?
Is there something I value more than obedience to Christ?
Do I see my money, possessions, work, and opportunities as mine—or as gifts entrusted to me by God?
Am I willing to follow Jesus wherever He leads?
For some people, following Jesus may involve giving generously, changing a financial habit, simplifying a lifestyle, or using wealth more intentionally for God’s purposes.
For others, the greater challenge may be surrendering an ambition, releasing the need for approval, forgiving someone, stepping away from control, or trusting God with an uncertain future.
It's worthwhile to examine our life to see if the path we're on is the one Jesus chose for us or the one we've chosen for ourselves. Just a few degrees off-course today will cause us to be miles off course in the future.
The Good News Is Not What We Can Do
After the rich young ruler walks away, the disciples are astonished. If someone wealthy, moral, and outwardly obedient cannot save himself, who can?
Jesus answers:
“With man it is impossible, but not with God. For all things are possible with God.”
— Mark 10:27 (ESV)
That is the hope of this story.
None of us can earn eternal life. None of us can fully free our own hearts from the things that compete with God. But what is impossible for us is possible with Him.
Jesus doesn’t call us to earn His love. He calls us to receive it, trust Him, and follow Him.
The rich young ruler was invited into something better than the security his wealth could offer. He was invited to follow Christ.
And that invitation still stands for us today.
A Final Reflection
The story of the rich young ruler is not meant to make us afraid of money or ashamed of having possessions.
It’s an invitation to examine our hearts.
Jesus looks at us with the same love He showed this young man. He sees the things we cling to, the places we rely on ourselves, and the areas we are hesitant to surrender.
Then He calls us to follow Him.
The question is not whether we have enough to give up. The question is whether we trust Jesus enough to place everything—including our money, possessions, ambitions, and future—under His care.
Christian Stewardship Network
Keep growing in biblical stewardship.
Get practical resources, encouragement, and upcoming opportunities from CSN.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), copyright © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
